How to choose between four wheels or a single rail for your mine
Join Our Newsletter - Get important industry news and analysis sent to your inbox – sign up to our e-Newsletter here
X

Trackless vs monorail transport: How to choose between four wheels or a single rail for your mine

19 Oct 2021

Sponsored by Ferrit Sponsored by Visit Company
Trackless vs monorail transport: How to choose between four wheels or a single rail for your mine
versus vs screen with two focus light effect

Transport systems are the most important support systems in your mine. They ensure your material, equipment, and people are transported in time and in the proper quantities. They also make a noticeable impact on the speed, efficiency, safety, and cost effectiveness of your mine’s operation.

A tale of two transport systems

Universal vehicles feature a wide range of slide-on / slide-off cassettes, which mount on their frame and are used for many different transport tasks.

Monorail locomotives are like suspended trains that ensure large-capacity transport of people or material over longer distances. When choosing between these two options, the pros and cons should be considered in the context of the following areas:

  1. Type of mining operation
  2. Material, equipment, and persons to be transported
  3. Roadways
  4. Geological conditions – subsoil and roof
  5. Versatility / Modularity
  6. Safety / Emissions

Type of mining operation

Trackless vehicles are popular in mining operations with gradients of less than 3°, such as open pit, block caving, room and pillar, and drift mining. They are also advantageous for use in mines that have an extensive network of roadways that require quick and efficient navigation.

The monorail system is a good choice for both horizontal and inclined mine shafts, as well as deep underground mining. They can operate in shafts with smaller dimensions and a wide range of gradients (up to 35°).

Material, equipment, and persons to be transported

Universal vehicles can carry out more tasks, as they feature slide-on / slide-off cassettes for transporting material, equipment, and persons. And if a wider variety of cassettes are required, costs can increase rapidly.

By comparison, the monorail system can transport much larger volumes, due containers that can be added and disconnected. It travels longer distances more efficiently and can navigate gradients up to 30°.

Universal vehicles and monorail systems can transport material, equipment (mining shearers, powered roof supports and other mining equipment), machine parts, and persons.

Roadways

Trackless vehicles require mine corridors that are wide and tall enough for them to maneuver, gradients up to 15° and a roadway with adequate subsoil. Subsoil management and maintenance are important considerations, as they require extra time and money. Traffic on the roadway can be a problem, as well as combining with other forms of transport.

Monorails can operate in narrower corridor (3.5m x 3.5m) and cross sections (up to 8m2), as well as negotiate horizontal curves down to 4m and vertical curves to 8m. Operation with gradients up to 20° without special tracks (up to 40° with rack and pinion tracks) is also possible. Monorail systems are easily combined with wheeled and tracked vehicles, relieve traffic on the roadway, and do not require subsoil management.

Installation

Nothing can beat the immediate use of trackless vehicles upon delivery, as well as their easy transport to other locations. Subsoil management, as well as the height, width, cross sections (no less than 18m2) and gradients (no more than 15°), are the only concerns. After the roadway is operational, ongoing inspections and maintenance are necessary.

Monorail systems require a suspended track, which is installed on a series of arch supports or anchored to the ceiling of the shaft. Regular inspections and maintenance are required for the track but are more cost effective than subsoil management.

Versatility / modularity

Both the Universal vehicle and Monorail system can be tailored to your mine’s specific requirements. The Universal vehicle is compatible with a wide variety of slide-on / slide-off cassettes and the monorail system features individual cabins that can be easily disconnected and added.

Safety / emissions

Trackless vehicles and monorail systems are safe, but there is a possibility that trackless vehicles could collide with people, other transport vehicles and obstacles in their path. Due to the suspended operation of monorails, collisions are eliminated.

If diesel engines are used, emissions of particulates occur, as well as extra noise created by the engines. Electric powered and battery powered operation of monorails are currently more common, which have no emissions. Battery-powered wheeled vehicles exist but are rare. Another consideration is the dust that wheeled vehicles create, which has a negative impact on air quality. Special trackless vehicles and monorail systems are available for use in mines with risks of explosion.

What’s the verdict?

Either of these systems would be an excellent choice for your mine. You just need to weigh the pros and cons of each before choosing the one that will serve your transport requirements best.

About FERRIT

Since 1993, FERRIT has specialised in transport solutions for deep mines. They offer a wide range of high-quality trackless vehicles and currently lead the world in the manufacture, engineering, tailored optimisation (with free-of-charge pre-feasibility study) and installation of monorail systems for underground mines across the globe.

Free Whitepaper

How to Reduce Costs with Mining Transport Systems

How can a support service like a transport system enable a coal mine to reduce operational costs by 50%, and provide a return on project investment within 3.5 years? In this case study, mining transport systems company Ferrit tells the story of how it delivered these impressive results to one of its clients.

 

By clicking the “Submit” button above, you accept and acknowledge that your data will be used by Ferrit.

We will also collect and use the information you provide for carefully considered and specific purposes, where we believe we have a legitimate interest in doing so, for example to send you communications about similar products and services we offer. We will always give you an option to opt out of any future communications from us. You can find out more about our legitimate interest activity in our privacy policy here. ‘We’ includes Verdict Media Limited and other GlobalData brands as detailed here.